Imagine losing an icon whose on-screen presence redefined what it means to be a multifaceted woman in Hollywood—Diane Keaton, who passed away on October 11, was not just the quirky Annie Hall; she was a powerhouse whose career spanned decades of unforgettable performances, proving that 'limitations' are just a word. But here's where it gets controversial: while some hail her as a trailblazer of independence, others argue her choices reinforced outdated stereotypes—could her signature style have been both empowering and limiting? Dive in to explore her top roles, and let's see why her legacy sparks endless debate. And this is the part most people miss: even in her later films, she brought depth that belied any notion of waning talent.
What an extensive filmography! What incredible versatility! Diane Keaton, who sadly left us on October 11, will always be synonymous with that iconic character from Annie Hall, complete with the hilarious outfits and memorable one-liners. Yet, her acting journey (and let's not forget her work behind the camera as a director) was vast and extraordinary. Starting with her breakout as a dissatisfied suburban housewife in Lovers and Other Strangers in 1970, she tackled over 80 diverse roles across a wide array of films—from timeless masterpieces like The Godfather and Manhattan to box-office smashes such as Father of the Bride and Something’s Gotta Give. She once remarked that she understood 'what my limitations are, and what I can and can’t do.' Looking back at her remarkable body of work, it's the perfect moment to question: what limitations, really? Were they self-imposed, or did Hollywood pigeonhole her? This is the kind of debate that could have fans arguing for hours—do you think acknowledging limitations held her back, or was it a strength that kept her grounded?
• Diane Keaton obituary: Oscar winner and symbol of independence (https://www.thetimes.com/article/diane-keaton-obituary-death-60sh503dg)
- Morning Glory (2010)
In the role of Colleen Peck, a satirical take on the television industry
PARAMOUNT/EVERETT/SHUTTERSTOCK
Keaton's impressive later films are sometimes overlooked, but she repeatedly demonstrated her skill as a reliable and strong supporting force, much like in this sharp satire about TV news. She portrays Colleen Peck, a polished daytime TV host reminiscent of Martha Stewart, who clashes with the irritable news anchor Mike Pomeroy, brought to life by Harrison Ford. Her standout scene comes during a live broadcast when she fires back at one of Pomeroy's snide remarks: 'And you are a fatuous, pretentious idiot. So, there’s that.' It's a moment of pure empowerment, showing how women's voices can cut through male ego—controversial, right? Some might say it's empowering, while others see it as tame. But here's where it gets interesting: does this reflect real-life gender dynamics in media?
- Manhattan Murder Mystery (1993)
Partnering with Woody Allen in Manhattan Murder Mystery
ALAMY
This final project with Woody Allen ranks among her finest achievements. She embodies the daring and spirited Carol, who insists on probing a potential murder in their neighborhood. He plays her anxious, easily rattled spouse, Larry, who's all about steering clear of drama. Their dynamic crackles with humor. Larry exclaims, 'What do you mean you snuck into his apartment, are you nuts?' and follows up with, 'What has gotten into you lately, for crying out loud? Save a little craziness for menopause!' It's a playful jab at societal expectations for women—does it celebrate boldness or stereotype midlife changes? This is the part most people miss: how the film subtly critiques marital roles.
- Shoot the Moon (1982)
Depicting Faith in Shoot the Moon
ALAMY
Director Alan Parker drew out a deeply moving performance from Keaton in this raw drama about a crumbling marriage (think of it as the Marriage Story of the early '80s, for beginners unfamiliar with the genre). She plays Faith, married to Albert Finney's unfaithful and self-absorbed writer, George. Despite abhorring his cheating, fearing his quick temper, and resenting his egocentrism, she's drawn into their tumultuous bond like a fierce character from an Edward Albee play, unable to break free. Their intense confrontation in a restaurant halfway through is unforgettable, highlighting the addiction to toxic relationships—a controversial take on love that begs the question: is staying in a bad marriage noble or foolish?
- Reds (1981)
Alongside Jack Nicholson, left, and Warren Beatty in Reds
ALAMY
Here, Keaton hits her stride right after The Godfather and her Oscar victory, bolstered by serious roles in challenging films like Looking for Mr Goodbar, giving her a gravitas akin to Meryl Streep. She's the centerpiece of this epic historical drama directed by Warren Beatty, serving as the lens through which the tale of his activist journalist John Reed is told. As the progressive feminist Louise Bryant, she anchors the story, even if Beatty gets the flashier moments—she truly holds the film together. And this is the part most people miss: how her performance elevated the narrative beyond mere history lesson.
• Diane Keaton obituary: Oscar winner and symbol of independence (https://www.thetimes.com/uk/obituaries/article/diane-keaton-obituary-death-60sh503dg)
- The First Wives Club (1996)
With Bette Midler, left, and Goldie Hawn in The First Wives Club
PARAMOUNT PICTURES/ANDY SCHWARTZ/ALAMY
Any list of Keaton's highlights must include this hilarious revenge comedy. As usual, she's the central voice and storyteller, guiding the cunning payback plots of the trio—herself alongside Bette Midler and Goldie Hawn. Sure, the storyline is fun, but it's the electric chemistry among the stars that steals the show. The movie was a huge hit, wrapping up with a memorable musical finale where Keaton bashfully belts out 'You Don’t Own Me.' It's a anthem of female liberation—controversial for its time, as some saw it as empowering, others as overly clichéd. Do you agree it captures the spirit of sisterhood?
- The Godfather (1972)
Portraying Kay, the partner and wife of Al Pacino’s Michael Corleone, in The Godfather
ALAMY
In what might seem like a supporting part but is actually crucial to the drama, Keaton serves as our entry point into the shadowy Corleone family underworld. As Kay, the initially innocent love interest who becomes Michael's wife, she makes the story more personal and relatable. For example, when Michael compares his crime boss father to a politician, Kay scoffs, 'You know how naive you sound? Senators and presidents don’t have men killed!' Michael counters wryly, 'Oh? Who’s being naive, Kay?' This exchange underscores the film's themes of innocence lost— a point that sparks debate: does Kay's arc humanize the mafia, or does it normalize corruption?
• Read more film reviews, guides about what to watch and interviews (https://www.thetimes.com/culture/film)
- Sleeper (1973)
In Sleeper
ALAMY
Nearly on par with Annie Hall among her eight collaborations with Woody Allen, this wild science fiction comedy lets Keaton shine as a changeable socialite in the 22nd century who morphs into a fierce rebel. (For newcomers, sci-fi comedies blend futuristic elements with humor, often satirizing society.) It's memorable just for her spot-on impression of Marlon Brando, mocking the actor's exaggerated style from A Streetcar Named Desire, with slumped shoulders, jutting jaw, and the drawn-out delivery, 'Well I say, “Ha!” You hear me?' Pure comedic brilliance. But here's where it gets controversial: is parodying legends like Brando genius or disrespectful?
- Annie Hall (1977)
With Allen in Annie Hall
SILVER SCREEN COLLECTION/GETTY IMAGES
This role is Keaton's magnum opus. Annie Hall catapulted her into stardom as a fresh, idealized female lead unlike any before—intellectual yet athletic, eccentric yet self-assured, outgoing and introverted, with a habit of gazing downward and murmuring nervously, 'Oh well, la dee dah, la dee dah' during stress. Dressed like the silent film star Buster Keaton, she was the ideal match for Allen's innovative romantic comedy, blending influences from the French New Wave, Preston Sturges' screwball antics, and TV-style documentaries. She fully inhabits the character and the movie itself. Her Best Actress Oscar was absolutely earned. And this is the part most people miss: how it redefined rom-coms for women. Yet, controversy looms—was she simply Allen's muse, or did her portrayal challenge norms? Do you think Annie Hall aged well, or is it a product of its era?
Two-for-one cinema tickets at Everyman
Times+ members can enjoy two-for-one cinema tickets at Everyman each Wednesday. Visit thetimes.com/timesplus (https://www.thetimes.com/timesplus/offers/two-for-one-cinema-tickets-at-everyman?utmsource=article&utmcampaign=timesplus_feature&utm) to find out more
Follow @timesculture (https://twitter.com/timesculture) to read the latest reviews
So, what do you think—did Diane Keaton's career transcend limitations, or did they define her? Is her legacy as a symbol of independence overstated? Share your thoughts in the comments: Agree or disagree with her self-assessment, and tell us your favorite role!
